Skip to content


The E-Sylum (12/8/2013)

Book Content

Ken Berger writes:

I have copy # 383 of Riddell's Monograph reprint. I've had it for years. I obtained it from a fellow San Diego collector, who obtained it in July 2003.

Bill Burd writes:

I have the 1969 reprint and it is number 403. I do not have an original.

Bill Gibbs writes:

Riddell Monograph Cover Coin World published two short articles in 1969 about the availability of the John Leonard Riddell monograph reprint. The first article appeared in the June 4, 1969, issue, noting that the book was available from an Edward P. Beals in California for $10. The second article noted that the book had been reprinted by the Sociedad Numismatica de Mexico and was available from that society, also for $10. Both articles had brief biographies of Riddell but provided no details about the decision to reprint his monograph.

The copy of the reprint in Coin World’s library is No. 80 of 550.

Riddell is a fascinating figure: brilliant, driven, mercurial. He knew nothing about melting and refining when President Van Buren appointed him to the position of melter and refiner at the New Orleans Mint in 1839. Some of his early efforts at performing his appointed tasks were disastrous; he lost a considerable amount of gold and silver on January 11, 1840. when glass vessels burst while they were being heated. He was eventually able to produce silver ingots for refining but continued, at least initially, to have problems refining gold, which was brought to the attention of officials in Philadelphia and Washington. However, he grew into the position and became quite skilled. He introduced techniques that would be used into the early 20th century.

He also was unpopular with some employees at the New Orleans Mint because of his actions, and became the subject of numerous complaints.

He fired two employees, claiming they were incompetent, and then sought to have one of his brothers appointed to fill one of the vacancies (another brother had already received an appointment at the facility). When Riddell failed to promote another employee, the disgruntled laborer spread rumors about Riddell, alleging incompetence, stealing, cowardice, default and that he had murdered Riddell’s recently dead wife. Riddell and his brothers tracked down the Mint employee and "chastised him on the piazza of his boarding house." Riddell was charged with assault and battery, and convicted. However, the judge chose to fine Riddell rather than imprison him because of his importance to the Mint. The assault resulted in months of correspondence between New Orleans and officials in the East as Mint superiors sought details on the incident.

Riddell's term as melter and refiner ended on Dec. 4, 1848, when Treasury Secretary Robert J. Walker dismissed him without explanation to the bewildered appointee.

Anyone wanting to learn more about Riddell should seek out one of the best biographies of Riddell, written by Karlem Riess and published Sept. 1, 1977, in Tulane Studies in Geology and Paleontology, two fields in which Riddell excelled. The article can be found at I used the article for my two-part article on Riddell in the October 11 and October 18, 1999, issues of Coin World .

George Kolbe writes:

Since 2002 Kolbe & Fanning has offered five original Riddells at auction and one in a fixed price list. Two reprints were sold, in 2004 and 2012; the first was part of a 22 item bulk lot. For many years the supply of Riddell reprints overwhelmed the demand but increased interest in recent years has reversed that trend. Partner David Fanning notes that we've had a copy of the reprint for sale on our website for a little while, too.

Dave Ginsburg writes:

I noticed a typo (from my original email) that I missed when I reviewed your draft - the Riddell Mint at New Orleans pamphlet was reprinted in the April 1968 issue of The Numismatist, not in the 1868 issue!

Thanks, everyone. -Editor

To read the earlier E-Sylum article, see: INFORMATION ON REPRINT OF RIDDELL'S 1845 MONOGRAPH SOUGHT (

Kolbe-Fanning 2014 Kreindler ad
NNP is 100% non-profit and independent // Your feedback is essential and welcome. // Your feedback is essential and welcome.